When you think “trick or treat,” your mind probably jumps straight to sweets. But for kids with allergies, dietary restrictions, or sugar-sensitive parents, a non-edible treat can be just as exciting — sometimes even more. And let’s be honest: if you’re the house handing out something cool and unexpected? You will be remembered.
Whether you're joining the Teal Pumpkin Project, embracing a sugar-free Halloween, or just want to mix it up, non-edible treats offer a fun, thoughtful way to include more kids and stand out on the street.
🧡 Planning a no-candy Halloween? Add your house to the Trick or Treat Map and tag it as non-edible treats available — so the right families can find you!
🎁 Five Non-Edible Halloween Treats Kids Will Love
These aren’t just filler items — they’re fun, practical, and surprisingly memorable. Many of them become next-day playground trades, classroom favourites, or bedtime treasures.
🛒 Glow Stick Bracelets (100 Pack)
Glow sticks are always a hit. Kids love cracking them, wearing them, and adding a bit of sparkle to their costume. They're also a low-cost way to increase visibility while walking in the dark — something parents will thank you for.
💡 Why it’s great: Affordable, bright, and universally loved
🎯 Best for: Busy streets, night-time safety, or sugar-free homes
🛒 Temporary Halloween Tattoos (Glow in the Dark!)
Pop a few into treat bags or set up a mini “tattoo station” at your door. It gives kids a moment to stop, choose their favourite, and get something they'll actually use. Parents love that there’s no sugar involved — and no smudgy chocolate fingers, either.
💡 Why it’s great: Mess-free fun that lasts longer than a chocolate bar
🎯 Best for: Crafty kids, classrooms, or low-mess front porch setups
🛒 Mini Halloween Erasers (60 Pack)
Mini erasers are the unsung heroes of Halloween night. They’re cute, seasonal, and actually serve a purpose beyond the sugar rush. If you live near a school, these will be a post-Halloween hit in pencil cases across the playground.
💡 Why it’s great: Actually useful, and surprisingly collectable
🎯 Best for: Little learners, teachers, or anyone who loves cute mini things
🛒 Halloween Bubbles (48 Bottles)
Halloween can be loud and overstimulating, especially for younger kids. A small bottle of bubbles gives them something soothing to focus on and helps avoid meltdowns mid-route. They’re also great for creating a magical vibe if you blow a few bubbles from your porch as families approach.
💡 Why it’s great: Sensory fun with zero allergens
🎯 Best for: Toddler-friendly houses or gentle, quiet routes
🛒 Fidget Toys - Halloween Edition (30 Pack)
Fidget toys are increasingly popular and appreciated, especially for kids who benefit from having something to keep their hands busy. From stretchy monsters to tiny pop-its, these make for a genuinely exciting surprise that won’t get eaten and forgotten.
💡 Why it’s great: Tactile, reusable, and great for focus
🎯 Best for: Sensory-sensitive kids, neurodivergent trick or treaters, or fidget fans
🎉 Final Trick: Mix and Match
You don’t have to go all-or-nothing. Many families put together mini goodie bags that include:
- 1 toy (like a fidget or eraser)
- 1 glow item
- 1 sweet (individually wrapped)
That way, you offer variety while still reducing sugar and increasing smiles.
🎃 How to Hand Out Non-Edible Treats Like a Pro
Want your stop to be the one kids remember (and return to next year)? It’s all in the delivery:
- Offer a choice: Set up two bowls — “Sweets” and “Surprises” — and let kids decide. It gives them a sense of autonomy and works great for families with multiple children with different needs.
- Make it themed: Got glow sticks? Light up your porch with lanterns. Giving bubbles? Add a small fog machine or cauldron. Props = fun.
- Let the map do the work: Use the Trick or Treat Map to label your stop as non-edible, teal pumpkin, or allergy-friendly so families can plan their route confidently.
- Create a moment: Even handing something out with a simple “want a surprise?” builds anticipation. It’s not just about the treat — it’s the experience.
Not on the map yet? It’s free and only takes a minute. Add your stop to the Trick or Treat Map here.
🌎 Why Non-Edible Treats Matter More Than Ever
This isn’t just a trend — it’s about making Halloween more inclusive.
- Food allergies affect 1 in 13 children in the US and UK
- Many kids with sensory issues struggle with sweets they can't chew or unwrap
- Some families simply want less sugar — and more play
- Non-edible treats don’t expire, don’t melt, and don’t cause dentist dread
The Teal Pumpkin Project, started by FARE, helped raise awareness of allergy-safe alternatives. But now, many families are embracing non-candy treats simply because they’re fun.
By offering something different, you’re helping Halloween evolve into something more thoughtful and accessible — while still keeping the magic.
📌 Planning Your Halloween?
Want to see which homes are handing out candy before you even knock? Use the Trick or Treat Map — your digital Halloween helper.
✅ View participating homes in your area
✅ Add your stop to the map for free
✅ Bookmark your favorites
✅ See opening hours so you don’t miss your window
✅ Filter by allergy-friendly treats, accessibility tags, and spooky extras (with an upgrade)
Join the fun at trickortreatmap.com and make your night a breeze.
🎃 You Might Also Like